Plan Commission Puts Off Vote on Fracking Permits, Begging City Council to Do Something

Categories: City Hall

photo (6).JPG
Texas Campaign for the Environment's Zac Trahan and a bunch of people wearing masks.
The Dallas Plan Commission voted to delay any decision on permitting natural gas wells in the Trinity River floodplain, telegraphing a clear message Thursday to City Council: Your move. Commissioner Gloria Tarpley remains none too pleased about being asked to consider a permit that currently runs afoul of city code's prohibition against drilling in floodplains and parkland.

Drilling opponents lined up to harangue the commissioners, who only a couple of months before had voted to deny driller Trinity East's application. Gary Stuard of Downwinders at Risk cited Jim Schutze's post here today, in which he nabs the wraith-like document that details City Manager Mary Suhm's pledge to Trinity East to throw her weight behind changes to city code barring fracking floodplains and parkland. This was right around the same time she assured the council that no such drilling would ever happen.

"At the very same time they were going behind our BACKS," he yelled.

Stuard also put Chairman Joe Alcantar in the hot seat, accusing him of leaning on the other commissioners to reconsider their votes in private. Stuard's cohort, as we noted earlier, filed a complaint against Alcantar with the District Attorney's Office, alleging violations of open meetings law.

After one speaker went on interminably, public comment time ran out, sparking furor among the attendees, who shouted, "MORE TIME! MORE TIME! MORE TIME!"

Jim Schermbeck of Downwinders at Risk made his way to the podium and beseeched the commission to vote for additional public comment time. He was rebuffed, and when he refused to leave the podium, Alcantar ordered the police to escort him out. A burly officer grabbed two fistfuls of Schermbeck's suit jacket and hauled him bodily out of the chambers.

Trinity East's advocates took to the podium next, to clarify what they say are misconceptions regarding the onsite gas processing plant they're seeking to build. Dallas Cothrum, who has represented Trinity East before the City Council and commission, said the plant would treat gas only from that site.

Chief Executive Officer Tom Blanton disputed claims that the plant would scrub benzene, a carcinogen, and hydrogen sulfide, a poisonous gas, from the natural gas. "Our facility will mostly separate a small amount of water and carbon dioxide." Testing of gas in nearby Irving, he claims, found no evidence of the dangerous compounds.

Commissioner Tarpley asked if the driller could move the plant further from the planned Elm Fork soccer complex, to which Blanton essentially replied: Uh, we'll look into that. Tarpley ended the meeting by imploring the City Council to take up the very city codes the permits would violate if Trinity East were allowed to drill.

The waiting game continues.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

Where are  the videos of these meetings! They clearly have a camera....are they being uploaded to YouTube? I'd love to see them.

Montemalone topcommenter

The DPC is incompetent. If the rules preclude drilling, then the permit is denied. How hard is that?

Why are they passing the buck? Because somebody is passing lots of bucks. Just find the overflowing pockets, prosecute, rinse, repeat.


Today shows why the CPC isn't a good place to have these hearings/debates on broad public policy instead of very specific SUPs. Their forum is geared for hearing disputes about fencing and signage. It allows 15 minutes for each side. Usually plenty of time to argue your case. However to give over 100 people only 30 minutes to testify about why they don't want three gas sites, and then send everyone else home, is just silly. It's during the work day. People have to take off from their jobs. Their time is as valuable as the Commission's but they're not ever treated as if it is. At least at City Council hearings, everyone gets their chance. The only time citizens have been disruptive in any way is when they have not been allowed to speak. This was true on January 10th and it was true today.


@Montemalone I doubt its anything as crass as cash that can be found in ones wall safe by the prying eyes of a interested Federal agency with a search warrant ..

Perhaps a favor for or from a mutual friend down the road   ?

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault