AT&T Doesn't Have Its Southern Dallas Golf Course Yet, But It Sure Has Balls

Categories: Schutze

SHZ_GetOffMyLawn_TitleImageV2.jpg
I am not calling names. If anything, I feel a certain admiration. The sheer audacity impresses me. And I do not know that it's an all-bad thing. I just wonder if this can really work.

This morning The Dallas Morning News, our city's only daily newspaper, has a piece on its front page in which a top executive at AT&T says the designer and even the construction boss at a proposed new golf course on city-owned land in southern Dallas should work basically for free.

Please remember: Far from being a public golf course, this will be a private restricted membership club, dominated by AT&T, where membership will cost some unspecified amount north of $150,000.

golf ball tee.jpg
AT&T Senior Vice President Ronald E. Spears offers what appear to be three reasons why golf course designers and construction contractors should be willing to more or less donate their services. First, it will be worth it just to have their names associated with such a prestigious project.

Second, it's sort of for the kids. Third, the golf course industry is in the ditch. They're not in a position to make demands, like being paid.

Apparently AT&T is in charge of the development of this new golf club, proposed for city land near Loop 12 and Interstate 45 in a belt of flood plain and forest on city-owned land in southern Dallas. I guess we knew that. I'm not sure it has ever been expressed explicitly.

Today's Morning News story does not state it explicitly. But if you pass the paper over a low flame and then hold it up to the mirror so the backwards disappearing ink reappears, it's clear. This will be the AT&T Golf Course in Southern Dallas. AT&T will run it.

Nevertheless, Spears is quoted in the story saying the course will not be, "... just a bunch of guys with lots of money building a toy for themselves."

All right, here is what strikes me. This is the AT&T southern Dallas golf course. AT&T will get 500 acres of taxpayer-owned land for free, plus some $12 million in earth-work and road-building paid for by city taxpayers.

Now they say they will also demand that the person who designs the golf course basically donate his or her services. And they even want the contractor over their part of the construction to work at cost only, without any mark-up.

Spears tells the News this morning he thinks one reason the designer and the contractor should work for free is that the course will be in southern Dallas and will serve two needy demographics: It will include some kind of adjacent set-aside mini-course for children who would not otherwise have access to golf. And either the real course or the miniature golf course off to the side will serve as a practice facility for the golf team at Southern Methodist University.

"This is not something for a bunch of rich people," Spears says. "We're trying to do something good for the city of Dallas, for the kids of South Dallas and to help SMU bring a national championship to Dallas."

OK. Poor kids. Got it. SMU kids. Got it. Plus, it's in the center of a bitterly poor part of town that never gets anything nice built in it. Got that too.

Then we get to the argument about the designer and the contractor working for free: "There aren't many people building courses in the United States," Spears tells the News. "In some cases, this allows people to kind of keep their business going, if you want to know the absolute unvarnished truth."

OK. Golf is on its ass anyway. Even young rich people are more interested in fly-fishing in Wyoming than trudging around in 200-degree heat hitting a ball. So beggars can't be choosers. If the designers and the contractors want to keep the plywood off their windows, they have to take what they can get, even if it's working at cost.

So, do you mind if we go back to the first thing Spears told them? He said this won't be "... just a bunch of guys with lots of money building a toy for themselves."

Free land. Free major earth work. Design and construction at cost. Private golf course with memberships north of $150,000, dominated by one corporation.

Is that not one sweet toy? I'm just saying. Look, I have a column coming out in this week's paper saying the area around the golf course is so utterly woebegone and feels so invisible to the rest of the world that people there are glad to see the golf course come in whether they or their great-great-grandchildren ever get to whack a ball on it or not.
It's something. They think something is better than nothing. Who am I to say they're wrong?

But I am stunned by the AT&T piece of it. By invoking every needy case from southern Dallas to SMU and all of southern Dallas to boot, they think they can get their own private golf course at some fraction of what it would cost at market rates. How much do you knock off for the free land and the $12 million in earth-moving? How much do you knock off for the free design and construction?

And you still get to charge six-figure fees and run it yourself. And then on top of that you get a front-page story in the local newspaper making you sound like the Mother Theresa of golf.

Like I say, I am awestruck. From here, I sit back and admire. If that works, you know what I suggest? I think the caddies should work for free, too, in exchange for the honor of being in the presence of such ingenious persons.

Maybe the rest of us should get in the spirit and give AT&T whatever it wants for free. Oh, wait. I forgot. We're already doing that.



Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
18 comments
aggie_cheme
aggie_cheme

Don't you know, "urban" golf courses do transform neighborhoods!  And Dallas' well connected, deep pocketed developers know exactly when to pinch the city for more free money with which to leverage public/semi-private development for private profit.  DMN's various other articles/blog entries provide enough details to connect the dots...

http://dallasmorningviewsblog.dallasnews.com/2012/12/evidence-suggest-urban-golf-courses-do-transform-neighborhoods.html/


http://www.dallasnews.com/news/community-news/dallas/headlines/20121210-real-estate-investor-plays-key-role-in-southern-dallas-golf-course-deal.ece

rroyb
rroyb

Jim:

Please get rid of the gun.

Thanks, db

bodaddle
bodaddle

How many buckets of water will be required to keep this baby green, green, green? And where will it come from?

Newtonianphysic
Newtonianphysic

@Dallas_Observer still don't know who will really go down there?

MikeWestEast
MikeWestEast

Why is AT&T this heavily involved? They need to back away before it becomes a local distraction. Its execs must have the idea the AT&T can carry the public with huge bank of goodwill. Not! Can't every really senior exec there qualify for Dallas Country club? This latest statement: why even make it public? Isn't it something you address in the Request for Proposal or discussions with firms that reply? This episode strikes me as something similar to the public relations over at Dallas Pnsions Board. A low level schmoe starts making pronouncements on things better left unsaid or said one on one. I predict soon you will see something from AT&T that thy are "just a contributor" to the foundation running this thing and that group will run all work associated with this course.

MisterMean
MisterMean

Wish that AT&T would focus on running thier business-thier land line phone service is 3rd world as well as thier other products too.  

WhiteWhale
WhiteWhale

Definition of personal chutzpah - First, you relieve yourself on your neighbor's front porch.  Second, you ring the door bell and demand toilet paper and a very thorough bottom wipe.  Third, you further demand compensation for having to live next to the unsanitary mess on their porch.  

Definition of corporate chutzpah - The proposed south Dallas golf course.

bifftannen
bifftannen

All golf courses are a blight upon the landscape.

Jack
Jack

i read the other day on the DMN blog that the city will lease the land for $10,000 a year. Thats $20 an acre per year.  To put that in context I pay $15,000 a year for a 2bed apt that takes up about a 1/4 of an acre. That means the value of my 1/4 acre slice of paradise here in area code 75215 is $1,250 or 62.5 times the value of the new golf course, and i don't even have a putting green! I also have to fork over $2,040 to ATT for my phone/internet service, so would take just 5 ATT customers to cover their rent for the year........But you know, I guess, it's all worth it if just one kid from Dixion Cirlce can putt-putt his way out of the hood.  Lord knows DISD can't seem to do it.

observist
observist topcommenter

Poor, underprivileged SMU golfers.  Probably grew up hitting rocks with old broom handles in the syringe-littered vacant lots of their inner-city neighborhoods.

Montemalone
Montemalone topcommenter

Wonder what Spears would say to ATT shareholders demanding he work for free, seein's how that would be a benefit to all the underprivileged phone company customers and it being such a privilege to work for a multinational conglomerate and all.

drtz
drtz

@MikeWestEast Why make it public?

a) No taxes

b) The city is ultimately responsible for it in the long-term

P1Gunter
P1Gunter

@MikeWestEast that's what i can't figure out either. I'm sure it's part PR and part tax deductions, but I'd think the ATTPAC would cover that. There's an angle to this story still we're not being told.

And then there's SMU. I don't get why the existing boathouse wasn't good enough for them, but at least White Rock makes sense. A golf course in Pleasant Grove that's further away than 4 courses seems odd. It'd be cheaper to just strike a contract with Tenison.

There's more to this story.

Guesty
Guesty

@Jack What does your complex get from you at the end of your lease?  Dallas will get a $40,000,000 golf course free and clear at the end of the lease.  

I'm not saying its a good deal, but your apartment lease certainly doesn't prove anything.

Jack
Jack

Sorry, my math was wrong. $10,000 for 500 acres = $20per acre.

$15,000 * 4 = $60,000 per acre / $20 per acre = 3,000 times the value of ATT's golf course.

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...