What Texas Drillers and Regulators Learned From the Barnett Shale

Jay Barker
Don't Frack My Park Day protesters at White Rock Lake on Saturday. If only the Railroad Commission had educated them better.
The development of North Texas' Barnett Shale did not go as smoothly as gas companies had hoped. The flaming water in Parker County, elevated levels of benzene in DISH, elevated rates of breast cancer in Flower Mound, and any number of other reports contributed to the perception among the general public that fracking is a dirty business and hazardous to neighbors' health. At the very least, the whole thing was a PR disaster.

That seems to be what the industry and regulators have taken away from their experience in the Barnett. Over the weekend, the Houston Chronicle explored how tactics changed when development began in South Texas' Eagle Ford Shale.

"I think the oil companies learned some lessons. The Railroad Commission learned some lessons from what happened in the Barnett shale, and we worked a lot harder," Railroad Commissioner David Porter told the paper.

The circumstances surrounding the two formations are different. Drilling in North Texas is centered in heavily populated suburbs, while the affected area in South Texas is predominately rural. That at least partly explains why there were 329 complaints filed last year with the Texas Commission of Environmental Quality for the Barnett area, while only 45 for the Eagle Ford, the Chronicle reported.

But it's also the result of lessons learned from the Barnett. They made minor changes to the way they operate, according to the article, such as reducing the amount of water used. Mostly, though, it seems to be a more coordinated PR.

"The perception was that the oil and gas industry was completely unregulated and could do whatever they wanted to," Porter told the Chronicle. "Which wasn't true, but if you're not telling people what you're doing, that [perception] can grow."

Actually, there's a good deal of truth to that, but, of course, it's not amenable to drillers when that's what the public believes.

Porter established a task force in South Texas in hopes of avoiding the headaches from the Barnett, highlighting the economic impacts of drilling and downplaying the health risks. So far, the evidence indicates it's working. If only they had thought of that here.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

nothing unusual here, engineers are always learning and applying those lessons as they go forward. this is something that the antis fail to understand. they believe that everything stands still.

too bad the antis didn't take any science or engineering courses


Too late. San Antonio recorded its first violation of the federal Clean Air Act this summer. A primary reason according to city officials was the massive amounts of smog-forming pollution coming from Eagle Ford gas mining. Austin will not be far behind. The same stuff that now makes it impossible for us to meet Clean Air Act standards in DFW is beginning to affect those Texas cities. What the industry learned was to obfuscate better, not take responsibility for their pollution.


 @pak152 Engineers yes, Industry no. Very glib with the generalities, piss poor on specifics. Engineers have already provided the equipment/methods to do it right - it's the industry that won't implement them in the field. Theory is great divorced from reality - a specialty when it comes to industry flunkies.


 @claytonauger San Antonio did violate federal Clean Air Act standards (which, by the way is a moving target).  But I bet that had nothing to do with winds from south of the border, right?

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

From the Vault