Fort Worth Senator Wendy Davis Wants to Use Strip Club Tax to Pay for Untested Rape Kits

Categories: Politics

Thumbnail image for stripper.jpg
Fort Worth Senator Wendy Davis announced this week that she'll be teaming up with the Texas Department of Public Safety to remind state law enforcement agencies, once again, that a new law requires them to report how many untested rape kits they have in evidence. At the same time, she announced the creation of a new, confidential legal hotline for sexual assault victims.

But it's the rape kit backlog -- and her novel approach to getting the funds to finally test them -- that's drawing the most attention.

As we've mentioned before, many counties, Dallas among them , have thousands of untested rape kits gathering dust in evidence. That's despite SB 1636, the law Senator Davis authored last session that requires them to report the total number of untested kits they have.

It seems that some agencies aren't reporting their numbers because they think that they'll then be required to actually test those kits, something they say they don't have the money to do. Davis says that's not so, and that the law is only meant to give the state "a clear picture of the backlog."

"You would think the police agencies would be the first among us to want to comply with the law," Tony Spangler, Davis' spokesman, told us. "Senator Davis thinks that clarifying what the intent of the law is will help alleviate the problem."

Davis would like to see those untested kits paid for using the proceeds from Texas' much-argued-about,recently upheld "pole tax," the one that collects an extra $5 from strip club patrons. She estimates it could cover around $4 million of the cost.

But strip club owners have long argued that it's unfair to ask them to pay for care for sexual assault victims, survivors of domestic violence or uninsured people -- all things that the money's been earmarked for at various times. In their argument before the Texas Supreme Court last year, they said the tax amounted to an infringement on their First Amendment free speech rights.

Dawn Rizos of the Lodge has been a vocal opponent of the tax; as she sees it, it implies that strip clubs are somehow responsible for sexual assault. "They're saying we exploit women somehow," she told us last year, during the last bout of fighting over the tax. Nonetheless, she said, the Lodge had paid some $600,000 towards the tax since 2008.

In upholding the law, Judge Nathan Hecht disagreed that the tax infringes on the club's free speech rights. In his opinion, he called the tax a restriction on "combining nude dancing...with the aggravating influence of alcohol consumption." Theoretically, strip clubs that don't serve alcohol (many of them) don't have to pay the tax.

And although Davis seems confident the money will be there when it's needed, and despite the stern talk from the judge, the state may not actually be working very hard to collect the tax -- and clubs, for obvious reasons, aren't leaping to pay it. That's according to Mike Precker, who was the Lodge's manager until fairly recently.

"Far as I know, the comptroller hasn't shown up at anybody's door demanding payment," he told us. "They're probably too busy hounding Planned Parenthood."

My Voice Nation Help
7 comments
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Cliffhanger
Cliffhanger

I don't frequently frequent such establishments, nor I do have a particular issue with having them around--I'm of the opinion that if anything, guys who go to those places to drink, ogle and blow off a little steam are probably LESS likely to cause other trouble as long as they remember to bring a designated driver. And I have long been a proponent on "sin taxes" for such establishments because, well, it just makes economic sense (although the trade off is our city needs to stop hassling the owners and trying to run them out of business).

As far as using the money for rape kits, why not? I don't see that where money is raised necessarily implies any connection for anything. The fact I have a job and pay income taxes doesn't mean I support subsidies for big oil, or the war in Afghanistan, just as many a conservative doesn't like seeing his tax dollars going to welfare programs or GM.

Processing rape kits, conducting investigations and getting bad people off the streets is better for club dancers, club patrons, and everybody else. Heck, I might go to clubs more often if I knew every time I did I was maybe helping take some rapist off the streets.

Amy S
Amy S

First, all establishments who sell poured alcohol remit 14% of liquor, beer, wine and cover charge sales to the state of Texas. Dallas gets 1/7th, or 2% of sales, which I believe is dedicated to our Convention Center's budget. I don't know where other cities dedicate their income.

While it sounds like a great purpose and solution, part of me is sad that it apparently can only be resolved with an additional burden on an industry primarily staffed by women. Yes, the patrons are male, but taxing the service reduces the demand. And then I hit myself in the forehead and remind myself that this is the nekked business, it must be evil. Right?

Of course men who buy their hooch at Centennial or Specs are never the rapists, right? They drink at home, or in other public settings, yet only pay 8.25% tax on their alcohol.

Do you know what the strip clubs might go for? Changing the mixed beverage taxes to an add-on tax (just like sales tax) instead of a gross receipts tax. And charge it on all alcohol sales, not just poured, recognizing that there is a burden that all drinking taxpayers must bear. This would raise retail bottled taxes from 8.25% to 14% the same as every pizzaria, restaurant or strip club pays.

And generate millions for the state of Texas.

G_David
G_David

If we make tourists and anybody else that wants to rent a car pay for our arenas, I see nothing wrong with this.  And the whole "free speech" defense is beyond laughable.

RTGolden
RTGolden

I thought Pole Taxes were unconstitutional?

Cutherd Cupcake
Cutherd Cupcake

Wendy Davis,

Put the hurting on them thar whoremongers, pornographers, drug dealers and wastrels!Strip clubs, often ironically called 'a gentleman's club' are nothing but a blight on society. Tax them cesspools until they dry up.

John_McKee
John_McKee

Fine, but only if we get to throw in the churches too.

Now Trending

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...