With Billy Allen's Compensation, Relief Begins for Exonerees Without the DNA Silver Bullet

Categories: Legal Battles

billy allen.jpg
ABC News
Billy Frederick Allen
Billy Frederick Allen served 26 years in prison for two drug-related murders in University Park. In February 2009, the Court of Criminal Appeals in Austin freed him, citing ineffective lawyering and "newly discovered evidence" that gave them "no confidence in the outcome of the trial."

In March 2010, Allen filed for compensation from the state under the newly enacted Tim Cole Act, which provides $160,000 for each year of wrongful imprisonment to be split between an upfront, lump-sum payment and a yearly annuity. He was due some $2 million. But the Texas Comptroller said the court's ruling wasn't enough. It didn't constitute "actual innocence," as defined in the letter of the law.

Allen's attorneys, Kris Moore and Kevin Glasheen, took his case to the Texas Supreme Court, the final arbiter, and last week, they won, in effect opening up the statutory compensation scheme to a new class of exonerees: Those without the incontrovertible silver bullet of DNA evidence.

"The law is the law, and has not changed as result of the Texas Supreme Court decision," Moore tells Unfair Park. "However, the application of that law by the Comptroller and the understanding of the law by the legal community will change. Not only in compensation, but the resources innocent individuals have when sitting in prison when they don't have DNA to prove their innocence.

"Think for one instance that we've known for several years that exonerations were going to have a spike and then decline. Cases that have DNA available will be tested and proven innocent or guilty, and then there will be newer cases where DNA works to ensure innocent individuals aren't convicted to begin with. Then that leaves an entire class, which is a vast majority of convictions, that don't have DNA evidence. But the law of constants tells us if you have innocent people with DNA evidence, you have innocent people without DNA evidence."

As explored in a recent cover story, there's a certain, satisfying comfort in the ironclad, scientific certitude of DNA matching. But what about the murky cases based on, in Allen's case, a palm print likely left under less-than-inculpatory circumstances, or the shifting terrain of a detective's memory? The low-hanging fruit has been plucked. What is left are the hard cases like Allen's, where "actual innocence" also means a convicted man or woman is "probably" innocent, and that "no reasonable juror" would have ever convicted him based on new evidence suppressed by either prosecutorial misconduct or an ineffective lawyer. These clauses and legal equivocations aren't as sexy as science, but they're no less worthy, Moore says. He believes it's these cases that may now get a second look by attorneys who see not winding paths to insolvency, but righteous work that pays the bills, too.

"What's interesting is when I took Billy Allen's case, most people looked at it as, 'Well, that's a loser.' While the law said one thing, the understanding or the assumption among many attorneys was that even though Billy Allen's claim was called an actual innocence claim, it's not really an actual innocence claim," Moore says. "It's complicated by the constitutional claim, but it's part of it. If one steps back and looks at the law, the letter of the law is very clear, in fact, that it is an innocence claim, and as such it was entitled to be compensated."


Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
7 comments
colorado disability lawyer
colorado disability lawyer

  Now we have reached the dead-zone of Colorado personal injury liability - Speeding and Alcohol. If you were involved in a motorcycle crash involving speeding or alcohol, you will probably be liable for any dangerous Denver motorcycle accidents. Speeding and alcohol will never receive good treatment from the judge or law enforcement because this is the primary preventable cause of most accidents.

denver workers comp attorney
denver workers comp attorney

 The budget also funds efforts to combat veteran homelessness issues. There is almost $1.4 billion set aside for efforts that will treat or prevent homelessness among veterans in the FY 2013 budget. This 33 percent increase represents a commitment to end veteran homelessness by 2015.

denver workers comp attorney
denver workers comp attorney

 The budget also funds efforts to combat veteran homelessness issues. There is almost $1.4 billion set aside for efforts that will treat or prevent homelessness among veterans in the FY 2013 budget. This 33 percent increase represents a commitment to end veteran homelessness by 2015.

denver workers comp attorney
denver workers comp attorney

 Due to this regrettable reality, when seeking an experienced personal injury attorney, Denver residents with whiplash injuries should contact Scott O'Sullivan for a free initial consultation. Not only has he successfully handled whiplash cases, but as a former insurance company lawyer, he understands insurance company tactics and knows how to counter their methods.

denver workers comp attorney
denver workers comp attorney

 it is estimated that the economic implications of whiplash run around $30 billion a year in the U.S. for loss of wages, medical expenses, sick and disability pay, etc. Although the condition is recognized as a legitimate medical complaint, supported by studies using high-tech cameras and crash-test dummies, insurance companies will sometimes try to dismiss whiplash as a bid to seek financial gain, rather than a true physiological injury.

denver workers comp attorney
denver workers comp attorney

 A relatively common injury, whiplash is damage to the bone structures and soft tissues of the neck, often caused by the rapid back and forth motion of the head and neck that occurs to occupants of automobiles involved in accidents with sudden jolts, such as rear-end crashes. Associated disorders can result, causing a chronic, disabling condition. In fact,

denver workers comp attorney
denver workers comp attorney

 A relatively common injury, whiplash is damage to the bone structures and soft tissues of the neck, often caused by the rapid back and forth motion of the head and neck that occurs to occupants of automobiles involved in accidents with sudden jolts, such as rear-end crashes. Associated disorders can result, causing a chronic, disabling condition. In fact,

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

Around The Web

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...