So, New EPA Regs Won't Cause Apocalyptic Blackouts in Texas After All?

Categories: The Environment

monticello.jpg
Luminant's Monticello
Over the course of the last month, both ERCOT and the North American Energy Reliability Corporation have warned of outages as early as next summer, due in large part, they say, to new regs issued by the EPA aimed at reducing the amount of mercury, sulfur dioxide and other pollutants released into the air by coal-fired power plants.

Gov. Rick Perry has decried the pollution limits as "heavy-handed" "job killers." State attorney general Greg Abbott has sued to halt their implementation. Downtown Dallas-based Luminant has complained that it doesn't have enough time to meet the deadlines, and that it will result in mothballed plants and layoffs. Of course, these rules -- which some would describe as long overdue -- have been coming since at least 1990, with the Clean Air Act Amendments passed during the presidency of George H.W. Bush.

Still, rotating outages are a source of concern, no? But then the Department of Energy didn't seem too worried. And now, according to a survey by the Associated Press, the blackouts-and-layoffs cudgel GOP lawmakers and the industry have been using to beat regulators about the head and neck looks a bit overstated. Shutdowns directly attributable to new EPA regs nationwide will number 35 at most, certainly not the cascading mothballing that has been forecast so direly. These are retired units in most cases, mind you, not entire plants.

The survey, based on interviews with plant operators and the EPA's own predictions of plant retirements, indicates most of the plants identified are aged and have "been allowed to run without modern pollution controls" for decades.

Among those to be mothballed are two units at Luminant's Monticello plant near Mount Pleasant, one of the top emitters of chromium and mercury in the country. ERCOT says it shouldn't cause any grid instability.

Anyhow, the EPA should be announcing its finalized rules for emissions of mercury this week, per The Washington Post. It'll be interesting to see what they will mean for Luminant's Big Brown plant, which emits more mercury than any plant in America. Surprisingly, it isn't on the list of known shutdowns.

As an interesting side note, none other than Jerome "The Bus" Bettis, a Steelers legend, has signed on as a spokesman for the new mercury regulations, Politico reports. Bettis was diagnosed with asthma as a teenager and has been an outspoken proponent of curbing power plant emissions. EPA estimates the new rules will prevent 120,000 cases of childhood asthma.


Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help
12 comments
Ed308
Ed308

enjoy your summers, no one would live here with out AC

claytonauger
claytonauger

What failed wind experiment? Last I saw wind was pulling its weight and new turbines on the coast will catch daytime peak demand when West Texas turbines don't.  But no question it's a lot cheaper to run obsolete centralized power plants without any of the legal pollution controls when you've already got them.

Mountain Creek
Mountain Creek

So, the DOE, the AP, and a former football player say "everything will be just fine".  I'll sleep easy tonight.

carbonfriend
carbonfriend

Hide and watch...not to mention the record price for basic energy.  Nice to see the demosaurs can still just say whatever they want.  Don't forget to say that pretty little puppies will die if we don't put a price on what we exhale.  oh wait, the insider crook Pelosi already used that one.

TimCov
TimCov

I still want to know what weather conditions they are assuming for these predictions (on both sides). Are they assuming a summer like last year (with the record demand we saw), a summer where we have few if any 100 degree days, or somewhere between the extremes. These assumptions could drastically affect power demand and what kind of power outages we are likely to see if the these plants are not allowed to come online.

DoubleOJoe
DoubleOJoe

Last time I checked, humans didn't exhale mercury, sulfur dioxide, or methane.

Brantley Hargrove
Brantley Hargrove

Good question. In reading some of these reports from NERC, ERCOT and the DOE, they incorporate a margin to allow for extremities of weather.

TimCov
TimCov

But, is it enough to account for a close to record summer (which long range forecasts are predicting for Texas this upcoming year).

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

Around The Web

From the Vault

 

General

Loading...