Welcome to blogs.dallasobserver.com
Blogs
  • News
    • News Home
    • Daily News
    • National
    • Letters to the Editor
    • Savage Love
  • Music
    • Music Home
    • Top Picks
    • Clubs Directory
    • Submit an Event
    • Digital Jukebox
    • Entertainment Ads
  • Calendar
    • Calendar Home
    • Top Picks
    • Submit an Event
    • Entertainment Ads
  • Restaurants
    • Restaurants Home
    • Restaurant Guide
    • Restaurant Reviews
    • City of Ate
    • Sponsored Online Menus
    • Happy Hour
    • Restaurant Ads
    • Restaurant Coupons
  •  
  • Arts
  • Movies
    • Movies Home
    • Now Showing
    • Movie Reviews
    • Movie Showtimes
    • Movie Ads
  • The Ads
    • Ad Index
    • Flip Book
    • Coupons
  • Classifieds
    • Free Classifieds
    • Personals
    • Virtual Job Fair
    • Personals Blog
    • Virtual Home Expo
    • Metroplex Living
  • Blogs
    • Blogs Home
    • Unfair Park
    • DC9 At Night
    • Sportatorium
    • City of Ate
  • Columns
    • Columns Home
    • You Said It
    • Buzz
    • Sports
    • Ask A Mexican
    • Savage Love
    • Free Will Astrology
  • Best Of
    • Best Of Home
    • Arts & Entertainment
    • Food & Drink
    • People & Places
    • Shopping & Services
    • Sports & Recreation
    • Best Of Ads
  • Bars/Clubs
    • Bars/Clubs Home
    • Bars/Clubs Ads
    • Bars / Clubs Coupons
  • Archives
    • Advanced Archive Search
    • Locations Map
    • Event Search
  • Reader Recommendations
  • Promotions
    • Events
    • Street Team
    • Join The Street Team
    • On Sale!
    • Free Stuff
    • Guinness St Patrick's Day
    • Facebook
    • St. Patrick's Day
  • Site Map

Top

blog

Stories

  • News

    Snow Kidding: You Don't Mess With Pete Delkus Via Twitter

    By Robert Wilonsky

    1
  • Schutze

    It's All a Game of Semantics Till the Big Rains Come

    By Jim Schutze

    2
  • From the RTF Dept.

    More or Less, the Entire Lineup for the Dallas Int'l Film Festival

    By Robert Wilonsky

    3
  • Schutze

    City Council Digs Hole, Plants Head in Community Gardens

    By Jim Schutze

    4
  • Biz

    Fine, Just Don't Turn North Texas Into California, OK? Thanks.

    By Robert Wilonsky

    5
  • Sports

    Kinda Love That "Texas Stadium Blowed Up" Logo Irving's Got

    By Robert Wilonsky

    6
  • Sports

    Reports: Hicks Has 20 Days to Decide Liverpool's Fate

    By Robert Wilonsky

    7
  • News

    The Man Hoping to Stage a "Revolution" at I-30, Malcolm X

    By Robert Wilonsky

    8
  • Sports

    Rangers Skipper Ron Washington "Is Not Here to Make Excuses"

    By Robert Wilonsky

    9
  • Schutze

    Why One Civics, Business Leader Can't Rest In Peace Yet

    By Jim Schutze

    10
  • News

    Lower Greenville's Loss Is Deep Ellum's Gain

    By Daniel Rodrigue

    11
  • Biz

    NYSE Threatens to Delist Blockbuster's Stock

    By Robert Wilonsky

    12
  • Religion

    The One About the Rabbi Who Tweeted Passover

    By Robert Wilonsky

    13
  • News

    Landmark to Sort Out Mid-Century Modern Problems

    By Robert Wilonsky

    14
  • Politics

    Tom Leppert Don't Need Your Money, Man. Wait. Really?

    By Sam Merten

    15
 
News You Can Actually Use, Actually

Some SMU Profs Offer Their "Loop Solution" to the Trinity River Toll Road

By Robert Wilonsky, Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 9:30AM
Comments (8)
Categories: News You Can Actually Use, Actually
David Matula, another smart guy against the Trinity River toll road. And he has six SMU profs to back him up. And those dudes are tough.

David W. Matula seems like a pretty smart dude. For the past, oh, 33 years he's been a professor of computer science and engineering at SMU. Pardon? Computers in 1974? Like, he must be from the future. Also been a teacher and researcher at the University of Texas at Austin, Stanford and a bunch of universities in Europe. And: "His research focuses on the foundations and applications of algorithm engineering with specific emphasis on computer arithmetic and graph/network algorithms." So, right -- Brainiac.

Well, on this day of the election, we've received a missive Matula sent to city council member Angela Hunt concerning the Trinity River toll road, along with an op-ed, titled "Efficient Traffic Management and Dallas's City Core," that is co-signed by Matula and six of his SMU colleagues. It details their opposition to the construction of the toll road. Both pieces are after the jump. OK, Jim, you can get off me now. --Robert Wilonsky

To: Ms. Angela Hunt

I am a Professor of Computer Science and Engineering at SMU and have long been interested in "network routing" regarding traffic, data communications, and other applications as part of my research. I have great objections to the Trinity Tollway for many reasons, but in the following I limit my objection to an issue that has received too little analysis.

The following is an Op-Ed that I have had signed by SEVEN SENIOR FACULTY of the engineering school at SMU, all agreeing that the issue of how to treat traffic flowing through a major city has not been adequately addressed. This is particularly relevant to the case where several major interstates meet where poor design can contribute heavy traffic to the local infrastructure unrelated to traffic simply flowing in or out of downtown as a destination.

Network routing theory clearly indicates voters should affirm the argument to keep any toll road out of the Trinity corridor. I intend to submit this as an Op-Ed to the Dallas Morning News. I would also be willing to send you a copy for your distribution to appropriate parties when I finish editing tonight. I would like to add that I would be available between now and Nov. 6 for any panel or interview you may be aware of to discuss these issues and related concerns.

I know the pressure is heavy from the other side but I believe their position has many holes that need simply to be professionally discussed by experts not under the influence of contracts to perform services benefiting from the tollway project and related mix-master expansion. You may check my overall vita at the web site engr.smu.edu/~matula I wish you success in a well run campaign against great odds,

David W. Matula
Professor of Computer Science and Engineering, Southern Methodist University

Following is the Corrected draft of Saturday Nov. 3 that will be used.

Efficient Traffic Management and Dallas's City Core

A principal assumption in the Trinity corridor debate is that more high speed radial access to the city core with an expensive overhaul of the down town mix-master is essential for efficient through (long haul) traffic management in-and-out of downtown. It should be pointed out that the state-of-the-art for traffic management when two or more major north-south and east-west interstate highways intersect is quite different. Radial design with wide spokes feeding a large interior "directional interchange hub" is an outdated and inflexible solution from the early 1960's era of interstate highway planning.

Directional interchanges are prone to unavoidable delays whenever any of the radial spokes has a loss of capacity. A more cost efficient solution for robust traffic movement is to have one or more high density traffic loops around the core. In contrast to a central hub, the loop allows N-S through traffic to travel either an eastern or western route and concurrently E-W through traffic can take either a northern or southern route.

The loop design has robust engineering properties allowing the North-East (NE) leg to load balance with the SW leg ( NW and SE legs similarly can load balance), allowing more robust response to a traffic disruption and more efficient utilization of capacity from a traffic management viewpoint. The loop solution is more efficient and less costly for handling through traffic allowing arterial traffic into the loop core only as a target destination requiring far less capacity. This is particularly effective when the large majority of the traffic into the core is through traffic.

A beneficial side effect is that the core becomes a livable center of a vibrant 21st century city, rather than a gigantic 1960's era directional interchange hub, with all the charm of an airport waiting room. Voters should recall that the Trinity Corridor bond issue they passed in the 1990's provided specifically for (1) flood control, (2) parks and lakes, and (3) a parkway. We ask that voters today seriously consider these compelling traffic engineering issues and vote for keeping any high speed toll way out of the Trinity Corridor.

As concerned engineering faculty in an institution within the city core, we believe sound traffic management here fits ideally with city core renewal and strongly urge voters to affirm the original intent of the trinity project and vote FOR Proposition 1 on November 6.

David W.Matula, Ph.D.,Computer Science, SMU

Gary Evans, Ph.D.,Electrical Eng., President of the Faculty Senate,SMU

Yildirim Hurmuzlu, Ph.D., Mechanical Eng., SMU

Mandyam Srinath, Ph.D., Electrical Eng., SMU

Tom Chen, Ph.D., Electrical Eng.,SMU

Sukumaran Nair, Ph.D.,P.E.,Computer Science, SMU

Mitchell Thorton, Ph.D.,P.E.,Computer Science, SMU

Comments (8) Write Comment
Share

Related Content

  • Charlie Green Bringing an Expanded Olivella's to Victory Park in October May 8, 2008
  • Despite Concerns About New Centennial Planned For Lower Greenville, Hunt Says She'll Give It the Benefit of the Doubt March 11, 2010
  • Hunt: Trinity Toll Road's Dead, So Let's "Get Going on Some Park Improvements" March 10, 2010
  • Why Is It, All of the Sudden, That Today's Starting to Feel Like 2007 All Over Again? March 10, 2010
  • Dallas Fire-Rescue Trying to Save Terilli's Facade. And, a Facebook Page to Help. March 2, 2010

More About:

  • David Matula
  • Southern Methodist University
  • Mechanical Eng
  • Transportation
  • Transportation Policy

Comments (8)

Bill Kennedy says:

Although it's by no means perfect, one simply has to look at the 3-loop system that surrounds Houston to see what this smart man is talking about.

As much as Houston is the perfect model for how NOT to design a city with no zoning rules, at least their loop systems don't try to funnel traffic all through the same core.

And what has that done for their CBD? Lofts, apts, a stadium, and revitalization!

Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 10:07AM
Wylie H. says:

This is a fantastic letter! Too bad it wasn't published earlier... what these guys say makes a lot of sense.

Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 10:34AM
Michael Olvera says:

Kind of a late endorsement, no?

Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 11:01AM
john k. says:

I too, believe in an educated solution to a simple problem. I feel there has been a conflict of interest by our elected officials using donated funds from interests that have much to gain for themselves and not for the people of Dallas.
Our officials should take a long look at themselves and go back into seclusion until after the first of the year.

Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 2:45PM
JJ says:

This seems like a typical engineer's solution--brilliant on paper, but with no practical application. Any estimate on what it would cost to build loops around Dallas (including the cost to condemn a *lot* of private property in every sector)?

Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 4:01PM
Dan Brantley says:

Until we realize that it is impossible to build enough roads, we will always be behind the curve. The only lasting solution is encouraging fewer cars on the roads we have. Unfortunately, since we all love our cars so much, the only way to do that may be to let the roads get so painfully bad that riding the bus becomes an attractive alternative.

Posted On: Tuesday, Nov. 6 2007 @ 4:06PM
Bill Betzen says:

This is a brilliant reflection on the ultimate best alternative for our city! We must work on a toll tag guided traffic management system that will help rush hour drivers bypass traffic congestion and provide multiple alternatives as blockage happens. Creating this bypass at the Loop 12/635 loop area around our city will give greater flexibility for our city. Automated billboards working with information from toll booths could quickly direct traffic around problems. In the process the 80% of mixmaster traffic that is though traffic not stopping in our city can be diverted. (See http://www.studentmotivation.org/TrinityRiverVoteClarificationProject/UnansweredQuestion.htm.) We will be able to create a less polluted and quieter central city wherein another barrier between north and south Dallas can be avoided, in spite of yesterday's confusing vote.

Posted On: Wednesday, Nov. 7 2007 @ 6:31AM
drewbanger says:

Is it just me, or was Prof. Matula's brilliant OP-ED a day late and a dollar short? Where was this meeting of the minds two weeks ago?

Posted On: Wednesday, Nov. 7 2007 @ 8:38AM

Write Comment


Comments may not show up immediately after submission. Please wait a minute after posting a comment for it to appear.

All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking "Post," you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.

Tools

Search Unfair Park


Follow

Email tips to tips@dallasobserver.com

SlideShows»

  • Not Your Grandma's St. Patrick's Day
  • Abe Vigoda (the band) / Vivian Girls at the Lounge
  • Dish Extra: Artin's Grill
  • More Slideshows >>

Most …

  • Next Top Model Behavior: Because, Sometimes, It's Just Nice to Wear a Hat
  • Do Not Mess With Pete Delkus, Or Else He Will Use Weather to Destroy You
  • Joel Kotkin's Coming to Town to Explain Why We're a "World Capital of the Future"
  • Premium Content: While We Argue Over a Word, a Risk Still Runs Through the City
  • For Your Viewing Pleasure, The Entire Dallas International Film Fest Lineup
  • More Recent Entries...
  • Who is Clay Jenkins? We'd Like to Know Too, But He Ain't Talkin'. (32)
  • Seeking a Mellower Political Tone, Dallas Coffee Partiers Talk Amongst Themselves (28)
  • Only in Arlington: Manny Pacquiao Saved His Biggest Hits for Post-Fight Concert (28)
  • You Know, What Dallas Has Always Needed Is An All-Ronald Reagan Station (27)
  • One in a Series, Apparently: Jobs Coming to North Texas From Taxifornia (23)
  • Despite SEC Filing Warning of Possible Chapter 11, Blockbuster Remains Defiant
  • Only in Arlington: Manny Pacquiao Saved His Biggest Hits for Post-Fight Concert
  • You Know, What Dallas Has Always Needed Is An All-Ronald Reagan Station
  • Sure, You Can't See Conan O'Brien on TV. But You Can Always Catch Him at SMU.
  • Jessica Simpson Talks Romo and Why, Yes, She May Indeed Be "Sexual Napalm"

Twitter Feed

Follow dallas_observer on Twitter

More Twitter >>

VVM on Digg

  • 1
    diggs
    Legal "marijuana" for sale in Miami
  • 1
    diggs
    World Naked Bike Ride (NSFW) - San Francisco - Slideshows
  • 1
    diggs
    The Runaways: Wild Thing - Page 1 - Music - Los Angeles - LA
  • 61
    diggs
    Cheech and Chong: 5 surprising facts
  • 2
    diggs
    Medical Marijuana Patient Robbed, Beaten; Cops Raid home
  • 3
    diggs
    Moms Gone Wired: One Woman's Journey Through the Mommy Blogo
  • 61
    diggs
    How a Bag of Rice Can Save Your iPhone’s Life
  • 32
    diggs
    Bus driver paws disabled woman, gets ass kicked
  • 1
    diggs
    SXSW: Mashable Party @ Buffalo Billiards - Hobohookah
  • 121
    diggs
    Wachovia Admits It Laundered Millions in Mexican Drug Cash
  • 234
    diggs
    Top 10 Kit Kat Flavors You’ve Probably Never Tried
  • 248
    diggs
    Woman Gardens Topless Near School; Kids Like It, Cops Don't
  • 276
    diggs
    Dad Tries to Sell Son on Craigslist for $5,000
  • 219
    diggs
    SXSW Interactive Is Dead
  • 182
    diggs
    Alex Chilton Of Big Star Dies In New Orleans
  • 379
    diggs
    Blockbuster Fights Bankruptcy: A Lost Cause?
  • 220
    diggs
    Teacher Arrested For Encouraging Teen Fights
  • 265
    diggs
    Fat People Are Making Us Into Fat People
  • 428
    diggs
    23-Year-Old Man Tries To Rob 63-Year-Old & Gets A Black Eye
  • 256
    diggs
    Top Five TV Themes Ripe for Mashup
  • 8774
    diggs
    Legalization of Marijuana Bill in California
  • 5801
    diggs
    Guess Who is Facing 21 Years in Prison?
  • 5051
    diggs
    Guys Dates Several Prostitutes. No Sex. Just Regular Dates.
  • 4605
    diggs
    Get Up, Stand Up: Ammiano Introduces Marijuana Legalization
  • 3753
    diggs
    Denver Airports Controversial 32 FT Zombie Mustang Sculpture
  • 3742
    diggs
    Guy Dumps His Cheating Girlfriend Live on Radio (Audio)
  • 2720
    diggs
    Meet Scientology's Worst Enemy
  • 2694
    diggs
    Decision Tree: Should I Buy an iPad? (PIC)
  • 2631
    diggs
    The best (PIC) of Colin Powell you'll see today.
  • 2589
    diggs
    Police Get The Wrong House In Galveston, Assault 12-Year old

Services

Health & Beauty

  • Avalon Salon

    View Ad | View Site
  • Doctor Eyecare

    View Ad | View Site

Legal Services

  • Cris Partida Law Office

    View Ad | View Site
More >>

Links

The Concession Stand

  • Al Dia
  • Daily Campus (SMU)
  • Denton Record Chronicle
  • Fort Worth Star-Telegram
  • McKinney Courier Gazette
  • Pegasus News
  • Quick
  • The Dallas Examiner
  • The Dallas Morning News

The Midway

  • Barking Dogs
  • Dallas Arena
  • Dallas Blog
  • Dallas Fort Worth Urban Forum
  • Dallas Progress
  • Dallas.Org
  • Dallas South
  • Ed Bark
  • FrontBurner
  • The Fine Line
  • Instant Tea
  • KERA Arts + Culture
  • Larry James Urban Daily
About Us | Work for Dallas Observer | Esubscribe | Free Classifieds | Advertising | Privacy Policy | Problem With the Site? | RSS | Site Map
©2010 Dallas Observer, LP. All rights reserved.