Wilco's Eight Albums, Ranked From Best to Worst

Categories: Commentary

wilco-studio-color-master.jpg
Courtesy of dBpm Records
Halfway through "I Am Trying To Break Your Heart," the leadoff track on 2002's Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. That's when I stopped listening to Wilco, which had been one of my favorite bands of the '90s because of their first three albums- A.M., Being There and Summerteeth, as well as the fab "Mermaid Avenue" collab with Billy Bragg.

In the blurps and hisses and detached vocals of Yankee's entree, I heard betrayal. Right there was an artsy overreach that ditched A.M. in favor of Radiohead. Suddenly, I became a folk purist at Newport 1965 when Bob Dylan desecrated his apprenticeship to Woody Guthrie with a screeching electric guitar. I took the new Wilco CD out of the player and flipped it against the wall.

Don't you just hate when musicians put their artistic aspirations above the expectations of their fans? In the cut-out bin of my heart you'll find Wha' ppen by English Beat, Neither Fish Nor Flesh by Terrence Trent D'Arby and YHF. This was not my Wilco. But I'm finding that a lot of my distaste for the "Yankee" stretch had to do with the timing. I think I was just burnt out on the band.

In anticipation of Wilco's return to Zilker Park (they were a top tier headliner in the inaurgural ACL Fest and remain a C3 pet band), I decided to lock myself inside a cabin for a weekend and listen to all the Wilco albums I had not heard all the way through before, from YHF through 2011's The Whole Love. I also replayed my old favorites, just to see how the ouerve stood up (like the cover of A Ghost Is Born.). All weekend that's all I listened to. Wilco, Wilco, Wilco. And now I want to go hunting for squirrels.

But what I came to realize during my hours of forced devotion was that the band's later records are generally better than the ones that made me a huge fan in the beginning. And I was way wrong about "I Am Trying To Break Your Heart."

Yankee Hotel Foxtrot came out a few months after Wilco played what I'm sure was its very worst show in Austin, at Stubb's eleven days after September 11, 2001. Guitarist Jay Bennett and drummer Ken Coomer were no longer in the band, with Jeff Tweedy playing all the guitar parts and the rootsy Coomer replaced by Glenn Kotche, who someone said played with Tortoise, which sounded about right. This was during the band's label limbo, after they were dropped by Warner Brothers and before they were signed to a Warners subsidiary, and the show just had a cloud over the stage.

Many of the songs were unfamiliar so after the show I met with Tweedy, to make sure I had the titles right on the new songs. As he recited "War on War, "Kamera," "Ashes of American Flags" and the others off a crumpled setlist, there was no feeling in his voice. I hadn't seen him so down since backstage after an Uncle Tupelo show at Club Dada in Dallas in 1993, when I proudly introduced my new bride to a room of guys with towels on their heads, staring at the floor.

You contrast those two bummers with Aug. 15, 1999, when Wilco had played an incredibly fun and loose 30-song "surprise" show at Antone's, opening with "Psycho Killer" by Talking Heads ending with Led Zep's "Immigrant Song." They touched down on everything I love about rock/soul/country on such originals as "I'm Always In Love," "Outtasite (Outta Mind)," "Casino Queen," "A Shot In the Arm," "New Madrid" (Tupelo's best song) and on and on. Also memorable: I was outside on Fifth Street, waiting for a cab, when Tweedy came bounding out of the club and thanked me for coming. My date was mightily impressed. "I told you I knew him," I said in the cab.

The first time I saw Uncle Tupelo, opening for Evan Johns and the H-Bombs at Lounge Ax in Chicago in 1990, they were a flannel-wearing mix of Husker Du, the Replacements and Soul Asylum. Not a coalminer song to be heard. They were good, but nothing special, in my opinion. Jeff started dating the club owner Sue Miller and she'd put him to work at the small bar at stage left, so the throngs pressed up front could get a beer without going through the whole crowd. I'd stand over there with him sometimes and get his opinion of the band onstage and I'll tell ya, not a big fan of roots rock bands was Mr. Tweedy, who was about 22 and newly sober. He was a punk rocker who was more in line, tastewise, with the noise artists that would bring Steve Albini out to the club: King Kong, Jesus Lizard, Cop Shoot Cop and the like. I recall an argument I had with him about "Marquee Moon" by Television, an album he worshipped, but one I bought the same day as Powerage by AC/DC and therefore rarely listened to.

The point is that Jeff always had an experimental bent and Wilco has been aggressively messing around with sound since the second album Being There, a self-expressionist "Exile" about accepting some responsibilities (marriage, fatherhood, bandleader) and rejecting others (spokesman of a generation.) The challenging soundscape of YHF should not have been so jarring.

Noise aesthetic aside, it's Tweedy's ownership of a fleet of simple, yet memorable melodies, caressed by a morning after voice, that sets Wilco apart from other bands of gifted players. But alternative rock's Artful Dodger had the great fortune of getting with adventurous guitarist Nels Cline from album five on, just when the mope-pop needed a lift. Bassist John Stirratt is Tweedy's musical wife, but Cline is his Mike Campbell, who I chose over all the other Jagger/ Richard models because

Tweedy is the Tom Petty of the WiFi set. He's consistently good, if not particularly original. Tweedy and Petty were both fanatics first, but ones who had enough talent to move from the front row to the stage.

On a scale of 1-10, Wilco doesn't have any 10s. There are bands who rock harder and softer and there are better songwriters. Stage presence? They get upstaged by the signer for the deaf. But Tweedy and company have a whole lot of 8s and 9s. Every album had four really good songs, four kinda good songs and a couple total snoozers.

The main thing I take away from my weekend of continuous Wilco music is that they don't know how to make a bad record. Now, whether they know how to make a truly great record is a matter of taste.

But here's how I imagine that a Wilco record is made. Jeff Tweedy is watching one of his beloved crime shows on TV and there's a street scene where a dealer and addict shake hands, exchanging a packet of drugs for a folded up bill. He thinks of the phrase "handshake drugs" and writes it in his notebook. The next morning he gets up and tries to write a song around that phrase. Where can I take it? He makes up a scenario of a controlled person breaking form, crossing a line he shouldn't have. He strums a few chords from old Cheap Trick records, slowed-down and rearranged, and pulls a melody out of his pocket. Then he meets the rest of the band at the Wilco Loft, plays them this new song called "Handshake Drugs" and they all work on their parts, knowing that they have to do something or the song will sound exactly like "Heavy Metal Drummer." Drummer Glenn Kotche cracks open a bottle of snap and we're on our way to the symphony in guitarist Nels Cline's head that turns into a 23-foot electric serpent.

Describing Wilco's music can be a little bit like Guy Fieri of the Food Network's take on a bite: "You get the heat of the guitar, then the crunchiness of the manmade mechanical backbeat. Then there's the melancholy smokiness of Tweedy's vocals." The Wilco sandwich is money, dude. They do what they do, got it down to a process of communication. And they never stopped being fans- that's important. They know what they'd want to hear if they were on the passenger side and that's what they make.

So there's not a whole lot of critical real estate between the worst Wilco album and the best. But here's how I would rate the eight studio efforts.


1. The Whole Love (2011)

Extra special: "Art of Almost"

Extra baggage: "Rising Red Lung"

Has Wilco ever sequenced as perfect a coupling as "Art of Almost," the band's theme song, and the driving organ-pop number "I Might"? Those are 11 minutes to get lost in the music. The album ends with the 12-minute anti-epic "One Sunday Morning," containing some of Tweedy's best lyrics. You have to find your own meaning, but "One Sunday" seems inspired by a troubled father-son relationship, with Tweedy's somber delivery over lovely piano accompaniment eventually leading to an understated jam that follows the tone of the proceedings. The album's a little soft in the middle, but it includes a song that predicted Diamond Rugs ("Standing O") and one ("Black Moon") that cuts through Townes Van Zandt's backyard on the way to the symphony.


2. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot (2002)

Extra special: "Heavy Metal Drummer"

Extra baggage: "Radio Cure"

The only Wilco album to sell more than 500,000 copies and the subject of a "making of" documentary, "YHF" is a "big picture" album whose strength is in the series of small details. Sing-song melodies that blossom in layers, an overall goin'-down-the-road-feelin'-fine vibe all working their way to this simple statement: "I'm the Man Who Loves You." And "Heavy Metal Drummer" or "Jesus Etc." will be the Wilco song on the 2085 compilation "Tunes From the Turn of the Century."


3. Summerteeth (1999)

Extra special: "I'm Always In Love"

Extra baggage: "My Darling"

You can use the first four letters of Sue Miller's name to spell "Muse." Recorded at Willie Nelson's Pedernales studio, this is Wilco's "Get Happy," an old jukebox of self-indulgence that somehow works. Tweedy's marriage was in trouble ("she's a jar with a heavy lid") and he missed his infant son, so he manufactured a new family of songs whose melodies echo with times of comfort- Motown, Big Star, a prescription refilled- while the lyrics are often disturbed. This is music you leave when the phone goes right to the machine and you're glad it did. Interestingly, this record was interrupted, with a long break to record "Mermaid Avenue" with Billy Bragg, then back to Pedernales.


4. Sky Blue Sky (2007)

Extra special: "Impossible Germany"

Extra baggage: "Walken"

Welcome Nels Cline. After being hired for the "Ghost Is Born" tour, the brilliant avant-garde-tarist Cline became a full-fledged member and gave the otherwise soft and reflective "Sky" its game-changing electric moments. The collaboration is at its most exhilarating on "Side With Seeds," a slow yearner elevated with electric swirls from Cline and yet its somber core is unshaken. One of the biggest criticisms about Wilco- that much of their music is built on snippets of old records- has an exhibit A with "Hate It Here," a song that nicks Van Morrison, the Beatles and Neil Young. But then you have songs of immaculate conception such as "On and On and On." In a totally solid body of work, this is Wilco's most cohesive album.



Advertisement

My Voice Nation Help
12 comments
jaffattak
jaffattak

"Wilco [doesn't] know how to make a bad record. Now, whether they know how to make a truly great record is a matter of taste."


Isn't that what you're here to do? Assert your taste on the verb-gobbling masses?


TWL over YHF? No.


Summerteeth over SBS and Being There? No.


Less Than You Think is the weakest song on AGIB? That song is how we're reminded of what the band had become. It starts off slow, with dry, rhaspy vocals and soft piano. It's like something off Being There. Then, a couple minutes in...BAM, with the guitar. As if to say, "in case you guys forgot, we still got Nels, check it out"


Sounds like someone needs another Wilco binge in the woods, or two, to sort things out.

lklee99
lklee99

It is astounding how tone-deaf, aesthetically challenged people get so much real estate to post their irrelevant opinions.

Astounding.

Really? "I'm Always In Love?" "Art of Almost"? "Heavy Metal Drummer"?

You missed their sonic, sentimental, passionate, intellectual, and brave intentions entirely.

Any more words on the subject would be wasted on you. Go cuddle-up with your Kansas records.

sesgym
sesgym

I can't with this list. The Whole Love ranked above YHF or A Ghost is Born.. and you don't like "Walken?" No.

sesgym
sesgym

I can't with this list. The Whole Love above YHF or A Ghost is Born? No. Also, you need to listen to "Walken" again. It's a fantastic track.

Andre' Avelar
Andre' Avelar

Wilco is an enigma...a mystery, wrapped in a riddle, which is part of the fun and genius of this band. You never REALLY know what to expect from them. My personal favorites are YHF, and Sky Blue Sky...but The Whole Love has some stellar moments....

Jon Pitt
Jon Pitt

Is there a worst? There is only bettrem better best I think

Logankelson
Logankelson

A Ghost is Born is the real winner. Great songs, great experimentation and a great window into what Jeff Tweedy is capable of doing when other members are no longer present. Nice article.

Max Ward
Max Ward

Noooo way. How does The Whole Love trump Yankee and Summerteeth?

Fort Live
Fort Live

Being There ranked way too low.... One of the Top 3 easily

moose
moose

@sesgymit's an opinion piece... as long as it's not contrarion for its own sake, it's difficult to be so unpopular as to be wrong.

Of course I'm going to defend it, though, because I agree with it. I didn't like "Walken" at all. Also TWL and YHF are my top 2, with AGIB in close 2nd.

Now Trending

Dallas Concert Tickets

Around The Web

From the Vault

 

Loading...