Miracle Whip Versus Mayo: What's Your Thanksgiving Sandwich Spread of Choice?

Categories: Whimsy

Thumbnail image for kthread-flickr-turkey.jpg
The day after Thanksgiving is known for two things. For those with materialistic inclinations, Black Friday is a day to shop till your AMEX hurts. For those who prefer couches, televisions, magazines and food, this is the greatest sandwich day of the year. But the biggest question isn't what is the best order to layer turkey, stuffing and cranberry sauce. The biggest question is what sandwich condiment will you choose.

Chances are you made up your mind long ago and have no interest in changing it. Me either.

My old man was a Hellmann's guy. I have distinct memories of him applying mayonnaise to practically everything, but especially burgers, sandwiches and plates of salt-and-peppered tomato slices straight from the garden. He worked mayo like a baker works frosting, sculpting creamy ridges with the edge of a butter knife till the entire surface of the sandwich bread, bun or whatever he was slathering, was covered in a layer of mayo no less than a quarter-inch thick.

My mother had a taste for the sweeter side. If she was making deviled eggs, potato salad or other recipe that called for it, she'd dutifully use mayonnaise, but for her own personal sandwich my mother preferred the tangy zip of Miracle Whip. I can still see those two glass jars side by side in the refrigerator. In the world of processed-emulsified-condiments, I lived in a house divided.

Leftovers 1.jpg

When I was young, I sided with my mother, using Miracle Whip on everything it should be used on, and probably a few things it should not. But as I got older, my tastes changed. When ketchup no longer appealed as a burger condiment, the images of creamy mayonnaise extruding from the sides of a bun as my father pressed it into place naturally filled the gap. When I learned to appreciate the flavor of hand-cut, fried potatoes, ketchup lost to mayonnaise again. What better for pairing with french fries than the classic French dressing?

Eventually mayo took the place of Miracle Whip, too. But as I completed my transformation there is just one sandwich that never quite tasted right with mayonnaise. Each year, the day after Thanksgiving, when I gather leftover remnants from the previous day's bounty and cram them between two slices of bread, Miracle Whip is hands down my condiment of choice.

I think it's the sweetness. While a significant dose of vinegar creates the "tang" most people perceive when tasting Miracle Whip, it actually contains more sugar than Hellmann's mayonnaise. Maybe I prefer it because that sugar subtly mimics the sweetness of cranberry sauce that goes so well with turkey, stuffing and whatever else I decide to pile on that day's sandwich.

Or maybe it's a nostalgia play. The taste of Miracle Whip and turkey takes me back to the holidays of my childhood, when my biggest problems were figuring out how to get out of washing the dishes and winnowing down my Christmas list. Turkey, dressing and Miracle Whip compose the flavors of lost times.

Whatever the reason, I don't think I'll ever be persuaded to change my mind. And chances are, you won't be either. So this Leftover-Turkey-Sandwich-Day, while your friends and family wonder the shopping malls of America securing more debt, look deep into the jar of your chosen condiment and reflect a bit. Chances are there's some history there.

Sponsor Content

My Voice Nation Help

I know this is an old thread, but...

I'll grit my teeth and accept MW in a pinch, but I'm a mayo guy.  On just about any sandwich.  And mayo with garden fresh tomatoes?!  Your old man and me would have gotten on fine. 

primi_timpano topcommenter

The question of layering order is much more interesting. If you want controversy, bring up whether arugula or other greens should be included, or cold/room temp/warm/hot dressing.


Im with Scott. As a kid I preferred miracle whip to mayo and hated mustard. Now the thanksgiving leftovers sandwich is one of only two sandwiches that I can eat that shit on. It is a total nostalgia play. Just like how I know that Coors Light sucks but it was the first beer that I actually had access to so I still buy it from time to time and love every cold filtered second of it.


Always use mayonnaise for a turkey sandwich, but of late there are so many to choose from. Dijonaise is a  favorite from Whole Foods. I have tried every mayonnaise on the grocery aisle, and have noticed a new brand called Duke. It is good. The Kraft black pepper mayonnaise is good. It is the grease in it that we crave. 


Miracle Whip is the pus secreted by Satan's infected big toe.


Scott, look out for A1 mayo..Wifey grabbed a bottle of it for me since I love A1, and it's amazing on most everything.


Mustard. You damn Yankees are the only reason mayo exists down here.

everlastingphelps topcommenter

Miracle whip until they changed the recipe a few years ago, but now mayonnaise.


It is sooooooooooooooooooooo incredibly easy to make mayo with egg yolks oil, lemon juice, herbs and a blender.  Once you have the real deal you will never go back.


No contest: Hellman's. Miracle Whip is for sissies.


scott.reitz moderator

@Greg820 I'm a fan myself, though I wish it would keep for more than a few days.

Now Trending

From the Vault