The Texas BBQ Posse Picks Ten Faves: Pecan Lodge Is Looking Good.

By Scott Reitz Wed., Mar. 13 2013 at 11:58 AM

Better than Snow?

If you spent some quality time with The Dallas Morning News on your couch this Sunday, you likely stumbled upon the BBQ Posse's latest piece, which lists a group of journalists' favorite barbecue places in Texas. And if you saw the map and noticed all of their spots were tightly grouped (at least by Texan standards), you undoubtedly started fantasizing about your own weekend-long brisket laden road trip.

Justin Fortune's Pecan Lodge came in at the number two spot on their list of the top six restaurants, which is huge. It's nice to see the popular Dallas based smokehouse on the same list as Franklin Barbecue and ahead of Snow's. Still, there are some details buried in the article that give me some pause.

The group collectively admits that they were recognized by many employees at the various restaurants they visited for the article. The pointed out pitmaster Fourton, came out to greet the group when they dined at Pecan Lodge, and Jeremiah McKenzie at Baby J's, told his kitchen crew to "put some pretty ribs" on their serving tray. Baby J's joint didn't make it to the top six, but apparently the ribs scored well. At the same time the article says special treatment only goes so far in barbecue, and while I agree there's no way to smoke a brisket for a special guest at the last second, it's quite easy to pick the very best looking brisket that's still available.

Judging barbecue is hard, though. I've had brisket at Pecan Lodge that has blown me out of the water, and I've had brisket there that was underwhelming. The best way to get to know any barbecue restaurant is to sample their meats over an extended period of time.

Heck, isn't spring break upon us? Maybe instead of a weekend-long trip you should book some hotels and make a week of it. You'll be able try each place out a couple of times. Sounds like a decent vacation to me.

Location Info

Venue

Map

Pecan Lodge

1010 S. Pearl Expressway, Dallas, TX

Category: Restaurant

0 user reviews	Write A Review
Save to foursquare

We Recommend

beda50

I agree with your comments about Pecan Lodge. I've eaten there several times and haven't been impressed by their brisket.

Mervis_Earl

No Tonto, I said posse.

cynicaloldbastard

BBQ is so hard to judge & rate. The last time, December, I was at Pecan Lodge the brisket was smoked perfectly. However, the meat had zero beef flavor. "Bad" brisket or too much of the new chemical that's being added to the cows diet prior to slaughter.

I've eaten at Louie Mueller with the Posse. The place is oozing with BBQ charm. The Posse and most other bloggers love it. I've had one excellent meal there, the other three meals, including the one with the Posse, were not nearly as good as the smoked brisket at Taylor Cafe across the street. That's my opinion, others disagree.

There are only a handful of places that are consistently above average. In my experience, Franklin's, Black's in Lockhart, City Market in Luling and the ribs at North Main BBQ in Euless are the best.

todd

@cynicaloldbastard Gimme Vencil over Louie. Love me some Taylor Cafe.

Twinwillow

@todd @cynicaloldbastard Taylor Cafe is a true hidden gem well off the beaten path and known only to the truest die-hard BBQ fans. And, me!

cleaver.gavin

1 Like

AMEN SCOTT

PREACH IT REITZ

What they need is a foreigner to review barbecue.

bealotcoolerifyoudid

@cleaver.gavin No, DMN already took Wilonsky, they can't take you too. I could only skim that article, the writing was drier than bad brisket.

cleaver.gavin

1 Like

@bealotcoolerifyoudid @cleaver.gavin Oh, that wasn't an audition. Plus, they've clearly already got barbecue experts who deeply love themselves, what do they need some self-deprecating idiot for